Sinead’s letter to Miley

Sinead O’Connor recently wrote an open letter to Miley Cyrus because Cyrus cited her video for “Nothing Compares 2 U” as an influence. It’s an interesting letter for a number of reasons, and I’m sharing parts of it here because it hits on topics we’ve discussed before, which can always use further discussion.

It is in fact the case that you will obscure your talent by allowing yourself to be pimped, whether its the music business or yourself doing the pimping.

Nothing but harm will come in the long run, from allowing yourself to be exploited, and it is absolutely NOT in ANY way an empowerment of yourself or any other young women, for you to send across the message that you are to be valued (even by you) more for your sexual appeal than your obvious talent.

Context is everything. O’Connor isn’t broadly condemning people who sell sexiness. She’s warning a musician that letting sexiness become the main “product” of her music career will cause harm to her and to girls who look up to her – while benefiting the manipulative music industry. This isn’t prudishness, it’s career advice. Too much sexiness becomes a total distraction from talent. And sexiness is more easily lost than talent. Which one should any musician bank on?

She goes on to say:

Yes, I’m suggesting you don’t care for yourself. That has to change. You ought be protected as a precious young lady by anyone in your employ and anyone around you, including you. This is a dangerous world. We don’t encourage our daughters to walk around naked in it because it makes them pray [sic] for animals and less than animals (a distressing majority of whom work in the music industry and the associated media).

The career advice has now turned personal. She may or may not be right to suggest Cyrus doesn’t care for herself. One might also argue that her comments about not encouraging girls to walk around naked border on “how not to get yourself raped” advice. But I think her real point is that the music industry attracts more than its fair share of predatory personalities, and Cyrus is very much on her own. Because the “rapists” are already present, all Cyrus – or O’Connor – can do is damage control. And some of the best damage control O’Connor knows of is showing them she’s not easily manipulated.

You also said in Rolling Stone that your look is based on mine. The look I chose, I chose on purpose at a time when my record company were encouraging me to do what you have done. I felt I would rather be judged on my talent and not my looks. I am happy that I made that choice, not least because I do not find myself on the proverbial rag heap now that I am almost 47 yrs of age.. which unfortunately many female artists who have based their image around their sexuality, end up on when they reach middle age.

And here we see that O’Connor is basing her advice on her perception of her own experience, which gives it more personal authenticity.

What do you think about this letter? Keep in mind we’re not talking about someone who’s thought, “I want to be a nude model” and has made that happen for herself. We’re talking about someone who apparently wants to be a musician, and has somehow become convinced the way to go about that is to emphasize sex over the music, which doesn’t really make sense.

Thoughts?

Comments

  1. D. says

    Every so often, I dredge up the video for “Nothing Compares 2 U” and marvel again at the images, most of which are Ms. O’Connor’s face singing with a sliding tear during the second verse. Skin. Bone structure. Expressive eyes.

    I don’t see any of that with Ms. Cyrus.

    As to this letter, possibly Ms. Cyrus might see its point when she is 47.

  2. sbg says

    We’re talking about someone who apparently wants to be a musician, and has somehow become convinced the way to go about that is to emphasize sex over the music, which doesn’t really make sense.

    It does in an industry which seems much more focused on image than actual quality of music. If you look right, they can fix your voice in the studio.

  3. says

    sbg,

    I get what you’re saying – I suppose it does make sense for now. But it won’t in a few years when she’s considered an over the hill old hag by the same people telling her she’s hot now.

    An additional thought I’ve had since writing this letter is that when we indicate it’s okay for a young woman to cash in on her sexiness – usually with the “it’s her choice” argument – we are saying it’s okay for women to take advantage of something that’s not made available to men. A lot of anti-feminist ignorant guys argue that the world is really unfair to THEM, not women, because women can just cash in by being sexy while the poor dudes have to wooooork. And while that’s a load of crap for about a million reasons (chief among them, many women are never considered “sexy” enough to cash in on anything), in saying it’s okay for young women to do this, are we kind of legitimizing what those guys complain about? Is it kind of like saying, “I want equality – except the draft. No draft for us ladies, please”?

    Maybe not. It’s something I’m still mulling over, but I realize it bugs me.

  4. sbg says

    I think so many don’t know HOW to think for the future. It’s instant or nothing, or instant is better than nothing. And really, “artists” these days can rake in a lot in a really short period of time, so that they wouldn’t NEED longevity if they’d only … think about the future.

    Doesn’t really seem like a fulfilling life to me, but hey.

    It’s a catch-22, you’re right, and a pretty big one. Except that sexiness probably is work for women. It’s extreme dieting and posing and goodness knows what else (I don’t know, because I ain’t sexy) in order to engender the basest responses out of people. It’s also brutal in that millions of people then assume the right they can denigrate the sexy woman’s every move and presume to know who she is based on what is very likely a manufactured role.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.